a preponderance of punctuation marks (reedrover) wrote,
a preponderance of punctuation marks

Hugos: The Dream-Quest of Vellitt Boe

The story was of a type that I like - an odyssey across expanses in the search for someone or something - and had the excellent, odd details that build a fantasy world for me. I liked the main character, an older and wiser Vellitt who thought she had settled down. I liked the setting, a fantasy land with nuance and mystery and cheery little flowers and rules that were mostly internally consistent. That said, the story was close to ruined on page 98 of 146 (epub, so your mileage may vary) when I read the line:

This was the last time she saw the seething sky of the dream lands.

Thank you so much.
You've ruined one of the two main questions.

I almost abandoned the story right there. But there was still a second question and its related following questions, so I went ahead with the journey. I'm not sorry I did, as the story continued to have good flavor, but I was no longer quite so invested in it.

As far as the actual writing goes, I'm torn. The adjective flavor was good and the crafting of the world was detailed and evocative. However, the serial comma splicing and the bastardized grammar strayed beyond even what I think of as normal for fantasy writing - or even "conversational" - into plain old run-on sentences. Most places where a colon, a semi-colon, or a solid period would fit correctly and neatly were taken up by yet another comma. And then there were colons which were being used as semi-colons to splice sentences together.

This story could have benefited strongly from a solid, grammarian copy editor.

I give it an A for story building and a C for story telling.

This entry was originally posted at http://reedrover.dreamwidth.org/2076957.html and has comment count unavailable comments so far. Please comment there using OpenID or here if that is your preference. I'm still reading both journals.
Tags: books, hugo_awards

  • Books: In Other Lands, by Sarah Reese Brennan

    In Other Lands, by Sarah Reese Brennan. Urban Fantasy/Fantasy. Hardcover, 432 pages. Keeping it. This book is what would happen if Gordon Korman's…

  • Books: Ready Player One, by Ernest Cline

    Ready Player One, by Ernest Cline. Science Fiction. epub, equivalent to 608 paperback pages. (2011) This has been on my to-read stack for a few…

  • Hugos, the progress report

    The progress report: Best Short Story - DONE Best Novelette - DONE, one abandoned (T-Rex) Best Fan Artist - DONE Best Professional Artist - DONE…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.