?

Log in

No account? Create an account
Goats, gripes, and grasping for greatness
Books: Princess Ben 
28th-Dec-2008 10:38 am
Summer
Last night I started and finished Princess Ben by Catherine Gilbert Murdock. This was definitely a different twist on a few old stories. Princess Ben is the niece of the king, who has no other heirs. When the King, his brother (Ben's father) and Ben's mother are killed while on a pilgrimage, Ben is taken over as Queen Sofia's pet project.

The story is told as an autobiography from a mature, adult-Ben perspective. Because of this, the narration voice is able to provide some analysis of Ben's actions and motives which provides the reader with appropriate depth - or shallowness - of Ben's actions. This is critical to making the story anything interesting or providing any tension, because the child-Ben is a shallow, food-obsessed, graceless girl who delights in succeeding at any resistance to Queen Sofia's attempts to polish her into a princess.

In her own description of herself, Princess Ben is a fat pig. In today's parlance, one might say that she has an "eating disorder" due to Queen Sofia's heartlessness, but the narrator makes it plain that Ben's overeating habits (problems) pre-date her parents' deaths. They also provide some of the redemption later on in the book, when Ben's attentions turn to a completely different set of obsessions.

You see, in the depths of her (redeemably non-stereotypical) exile in her Queen Aunt's castle tower, Ben discovers that she has magical powers. She discovers the secret passageways around the castle, and finds a tower with a spellbook in it that begins to teach her how to use her powers. In authorial brilliance, Murdock does not explain the powers of the tower and its contents. Like children (and like Ben) we the readers are forced to accept that the tower's contents simply are and do what they please.

The love/hate relationship with the next kingdom over the mountain gets old quickly. The plot devices with which Murdock moves Ben to the locations needed for interaction with the "enemy" are rather aged, though her particular flourishes on them are amusing and speedy. I'm too jaded to enjoy the "invading each other's dreams" plot filler at this point, so I must admit that I barely skimmed over the brief dream interludes.

The various foreign personalities are unfortunately limited by page size, so remain far flatter than one might prefer as an adult reader. Murdock does provide a strong nod towards the feminist fantasy crowd with a strong-but-brief rant by Princess Ben regarding how much work becoming an accomplished princess can be.

I will be interested to hear what my niece thinks of this book when I send it to her.
Comments 
29th-Dec-2008 11:02 pm (UTC)
Heck, I want to read it too. Your review makes it a new "want". Not a long list right now, unfortunately. But I'll snag it from M when she's done. Or before she reads it, given how many excellent books she was given last week.

Oh, and I just read When Demons Walk . It has to be my new favorite Briggs book. Don't know what Mom will think, but I loved it. Like an Eddings at his best. It has everything I want in a great story, including the immense frustration that there aren't more books about those characters yet. I'm hoping that she takes heed and writes a series for it. And of course, since I want everything, they all need to be equally excellent.
30th-Dec-2008 06:10 pm (UTC)
I'll try to remember to send Princess Ben off to you soonish.

Oddly, according to something I read, When Demons Walk is actually book 2 of something. I haven't gone hunting yet to figure out what the first book is, but someday.
9th-Jan-2009 03:19 am (UTC)
Based on your write-up, I have snagged Princess Ben on CD from the Fairfax library system. When I remember do to it, I'll copy all the CDs off so I can put it on my mp3 player (I delete all copies when I finish, soas to actually be vaguely legal). Thanks for the suggestion! We'll see if it fits in with my particular brand of "readable book". :D
9th-Jan-2009 11:30 am (UTC)
I'll be interested to hear what you think of the audio version, and of the story as a whole.
This page was loaded Apr 19th 2019, 12:43 pm GMT.